Join the Discussion
Bet 223
Kathleen A. Hansen predicts: "By 2015, standardized tests for high school students in every state of the United States will directly evaluate students' understanding of the differences between scientific laws, scientific theories and the kinds of things often called theories outside the scientific community."
Re: Bet 223
Posted by Gary Yuen
on Feb 18, 02006 at 04:42PM
Hi Kathleen,
I sure hope so.
When will we start to teach science, philosophy, ethics, perhaps theory in any subject in high school? It may need to begin before.
We might need more free thinking education. Gardner is writing a book about education. When will it be done, btw? I don't think we'll talk to children by Socratic method or something similar method for a few centuries. We will require that for an 18 year old to be considered a serious academic.
But just tests and basic understanding? Maybe. France's elite grad-prep schools can turn out geniuses under 20. The under 20s who get into the École Normale Superière and go on to be major thinkers and scientists; they take quite difficult tests to get into such schools.
Can we do that here? Is that what we should do?
My challenge
Scientific laws and scientific theory are based on the scientific method. By definition, the scientific method allows for the continual application of tests to the hypothesis / theory / law and provides a means for accounting for new observations. This includes a dynamic process for handling when observations are made that render previous hypothesis / theory / laws incorrect.
The observations for evolution are strong, yet it is not considered a law because of the missing observations that are required to solidify the theory into a law. This is not a function of the education system as much as it is a lack of the solid scientific evidence required to meet the standards of the scientific method. Thus, there is controversy within the scientific community, as no scientist can correctly apply scientific method and conclude evolution to be a scientific law.
The philosophical logic of the argument is flawed because Ms. Hansen appears to suggest that if definitions of the scientific method were better known, that more people would embrace the theory of evolution. This blatantly disregards the very real presence of faith and religion, which are very powerful motivators. Thus, even if every student were fully aware of the scientific method, evolution would still not likely be universally accepted.
The practical logic of Ms. Hansen’s argument is flawed because it requires acceptance of an interpretation of differences which is not clear or universally accepted. Her prediction states: “every state of the United States will directly evaluate students' understanding of the differences between scientific laws, scientific theories and the kinds of things often called theories outside the scientific community.”, which would require definition of the differences and universal acceptance of that definition by the legislating bodies responsible for creating the standardized tests. Not only is this politically impractical, but it would certainly be controversial within the scientific community, and thus is scientifically impractical.
The brilliance of the scientific method is that it provides a dynamic system to handle the dynamics of scientific discovery. An example of a scientific theory today may be rendered mute by a scientific observation tomorrow, thus by definition scientific laws and theories are only etched in pencil
awaiting the eraser of better understanding and knowledge. How do you define that, which by definition, is indefinable?
Scientific method is already part of standardized testing as well as science curriculums everywhere. However, it will not be by 2015, if ever, that standardized tests can promote state defined differences between laws / theories / non-scientific-theories. To do so would be to instill something other than the scientific method
something that is rigid and unchangeable in a field of constant change.
I hope you're right, but I voted no ...
... as we can see from comments, the misunderstanding persists even among quite literate adults (whose lives must seem perilous without a "law" of gravity). Secondly, there is no compelling reason to believe there will be decline in the particular sort of religious belief that resists such scientific concepts being taught. And finally, by including every state in the nation, the wording of the wager assumes either a federal mandate or a shared effort of a comprehensiveness that I find unlikely.
Posted by exer exe
on Oct 15, 02009 at 02:43AM
thanks
porno izle
My prediction focuses on a simpler issue: the definitions of scientific laws and scientific theories.
buy levothroid
buy prozac
buy bactrim
acomplia 20 mg
cialis without prescription
discount cialis
generic levitra
ghd hair straighteners for sale
Posted by chen xi
on Oct 26, 02009 at 05:20PM
Your article is write very well, I like it very much ~
If you have any needs, they can provide the following for your reference:
ghd Hair Straightener
ugg boots
nike sb dunks
dunks sb
ghd straighteners
nike dunks
Bose on ear headphones
ghd Hair Straighteners
ugg sale
Hair straightener
ugg boots uk
Bose in ear headphones
I wish you have a wonderful day!Thank you.
Posted by Bill Wang
on Oct 26, 02009 at 09:27PM
UGG boots, UGG Classic Tall Boots, UGG Classic Cardy boots, UGG Classic Metallic Boots, UGG Classic Mini Boots, UGG Classic Short Boots, UGG Ultra Short Boots, UGG Ultra Tall Boots, UGG Bailey Button Boots, UGG Nightfall Boots, UGG Sundance II Boots, UGG Boots 5812, UGG Boots 5802, UGG Boots 5819, UGG Boots 5854, UGG Boots 5825, UGG Boots 5815, UGG Boots 5225, Timberland shoes, Gucci shoes, Prada shoes, Gucci bags, Coach bags, Prada bags, Adidas sunglassess, D&G sunglasses , Dior sunglasses, MLB jerseys, NFL jerseys, NBA jerseys, NHL jerseys
Thank you very much for this information.
Good post thanks for sharin.
I like this site ;)
----------------------------------
porno izle
mp3 indir
porno izle
film seyret
----------------------------------
nikedunks
Posted by mary lucy
on Oct 28, 02009 at 12:33AM
More and more people like to wear dunks sb basketball shoes.nike dunk sb-Strong grips,durable ankle support and very comfort.Nike dunks are the most desirable skate shoes.Get your Nike Dunk SB Now!Free shipping.
ugg boots uk
All kinds of adidas shoes On Sale.We hot sell the latest Adidas Shoes&
cheap adidas shoes.The products are first-class quality,
adidas shoes salewelcome you to purchase.
In the present lively world, food and clothing put on the line in our life have already to obtain the sublimation, life needs the entertainment, in the market shoes design is all kinds, ugg boots and classic ugg boots were the riotous multi-colors, each kinds of color and design are finitely looks like the young women''s hairstyle , every day them use the ghd Straighteners to changes themself hairstyle.Please pay attention to the ghd Hair Straighteners site .
People to enjoy music, a need for a high-quality sound equipment to show the moving melody to enhance the music quality of life,It is the use of bose headphones.Now Bose headphones for sale in hot,Let''s go to buy bose headphones.
ugg bailey button boots
ugg boots
Posted by mary lucy
on Nov 04, 02009 at 01:28AM
ugg boots sale-Warm ugg boots for all the family remain at the heart of our collection,find your favorite UGGs from stunning designs-ugg boots uk.
All kinds of adidas shoes On Sale.We hot sell the latest Adidas Shoes&
cheap adidas shoes.The products are first-class quality,
adidas shoes sale welcome you to purchase.
UGG Boots sale
uggs bailey button
Classic Tall UGG Boots
Classic Short UGG Boots
nike dunk high
bose in ear
ghd straighteners
ghd
links of london
Posted by lucy king
on Nov 05, 02009 at 09:26PM
links of london Pendant
links of london Pendant
links london Sweetie Bracelets
links london Sweetie Bracelets
links london Friendship Bracelets
links london Friendship Bracelets
links london Charms
links london Charms
links london Bracelets
links london Bracelets
links london Necklaces
links london Necklaces
links london Earrings
links london Earrings
links london Rings
links london Rings
links london Pendants
links london Pendants
links london Silver Chain
links london Silver Chain
gucci men's shoes
one day i went shopping outside,and in an gucci shoes store,I found some kinds of gucci shoes i love most.they are:
ed hardy mens tops ed hardy mens tops ed hardy mens hoodies ed hardy mens hoodies ed hardy mens jeans ed hardy mens jeans ed hardy mens wwim trunks ed hardy mens wwim trunks ed hardy mens underwear ed hardy mens underwear ed hardy mens shoes ed hardy mens shoes ed hardy womens swimwear ed hardy womens swimwear ed hardy womenst-shirt ed hardy womenst-shirt ed hardy womens tops ed hardy womens tops ed hardy womens tanks ed hardy womens tanks ed hardy womens hoodies ed hardy womens hoodies ed hardy womens jeans ed hardy womens jeans
Comments are temporarily closed.
Posted by admin
Due to SPAM problems we have disabled commenting on Long Bets until we can institute
automated filtering. Sorry for the inconvenience.