Prediction 448

Duration 92 years (02008-02100)

“By 2100, a small self-sustainable population will be living off this planet”

Predictor
Michael H. Martin-Smith

Challenger
TBA

Vote

When you vote, your name, today's date and who you are siding with will be added to this prediction's permanent record. Please sign in to vote.

side with predictor
side with challenger
 

17 people (61%)

11 people (39%)

details »

Discuss & Share

Add your voice to a conversation with the bettors:

Join the discussion »

Bookmark this bet, and share it with friends:

Martin-Smith’s Argument

O'Neill's ideas for Island space colonies launched considerable public interest, which has inspired many of the active players in today's private space industry. The X Prize has resulted in the first steps towards privately affordable space flight, while inflatable prototype habitats are already in orbit. Closed loop recycling of water and oxygen is already active on board the ISS. IN the 2020s a Moon Race should have led to bases on the Moon, with later ones on NEOs, leading to solar power satellite construction, and a growing space hotel industry. Such hotels will grow in evolutionary steps towards full-blown free floating city states, as proposed by O'Neill et al. Overcrowding, persecution/totalitarianism, and the classic search for new opportunities and new horizons will produce the people and the motives for such expansion. The end result will be a Cosmic Diaspora over the next 1,000 years, with a humanised Galaxy by 1,000,000 AD. The alternative is extinction.

Challenge Martin-Smith!

Sign in to challenge Michael H. Martin-Smith to a bet on this prediction!

Join the Discussion

No way out

Try to take a trip to the North Pole (on Earth), in the winter, with the same equipment and supplies that you anticipate to be able to take to space. Survival there for the same duration of time as would be necessary in space to avoid extinction is a pure fantasy.

What alternatives are in space that are absent on Earth that would prevent extinction? Space? The argument is inconsistent.

All Utopian ideas had been tried ... and failed. Wake up, and accept it.

self-sustainable?

As in they grown their own Martian crops?

I'm not sure what to think of this. 2100 is long way from 2008.
Plenty of time in order to make this feasible.

Materials, Mechanicals, Energy

Self-sufficient survival in Antarctica, to take an example, would be relatively simple with current technology if money and energy supply were not issues. With current trends, we can expect technological capacity, at least, to become much less expensive as time goes by.

What's needed, then, is cheaper, easier energy. If a future energy supply that is inexpensive, reliable, and transportable (or easily reproducible) is developed, then survival in many inhospitable places would become much simpler. Antarctica or Mars, certainly.

Of course, getting yourself and your equipment to Mars is another story. Still, for a 'small population', it's certainly plausible.

Mars

Already over a million 'people' originating from earth live on Mars.

Mars

Already over a million 'people' originating from earth live on Mars.

Even th first Milestone will not hold

I see a zero chance that another human sets his or her foot on the moon until 2020. Even a limited base will not come before 2030.
Mars will not be visited before 2050 (see my prediction).
So we'll see that even the time between the first visits on Moon and the second ones will be >50 years. So 100 years is too limited a time for such a development.

Private space travel will come, but currently funding is hard and the companies learn that just want of doing things easier does not do away with the problems.

Plus: There's nothing really to gain from colonies, yet. There simply IS no other inhabitable planet for humans in this solar system. So the "Exploration of foreign continents" paradigm doesn't apply: only those (continents) which were inhabitable became inhabited, no self-sustaining colonies in Antarctica, yet, 100 years after the exploration started.

Exponential progress in technology

Based on current rates of technological development, along with gradually falling costs of launch vehicles, advances in materials technology, the increasing commercialisation of space, improving techniques in food/energy/resource management, and the timescale involved, I think it's fair to say there'll be at least one permanent colony on either Mars or the Moon by 2100.

In fact, 2100 is probably a conservative estimate. People seem to forget the exponential trends which are driving technological progress, and instead think in terms of linear progress (look up "Law of Accelerating Returns" on Wikipedia). This exponential growth in science and technology will substantially drive down costs.

Plus, we'll likely have fusion power by the 2050s - giving us a major incentive to begin mining the Moon for Helium-3 (this isotope is rare on Earth). Furthermore, we'll see major breakthroughs in propulsion technology between now and 2100, making these colonies far easier to access and develop.

Nine decades is a long time, and a heck of a lot can happen between now and then. If you look back the same length of time, to 1920, we had barely discovered flight back then. We had nothing like computers, or satellites, or mobile phones, etc. Now look forwards to 2100, with a massively accelerated rate of progress - including the assistance of hyperfast AI, which will further boost our knowledge of nanotech materials, engineering, physical processes, cost efficiency and so on. In my view it's obvious there will be major advances in space exploration.

Growth may be exponential but not in Space Flight

You may see exponential growth in technology overall, but right now there is little or even negative growth in (manned) spaceflight.
40 Years ago man flew to the moon, for the US that was using the 3rd generation of manned spacecraft being developed within a decade. Development in the USSR was similar.
Now, moon landings this are not going to be repeated for at least another 10-15 years. Since 40 years ago only one new spacecraft was being developed, and that was brought into service more than 25 years ago.
Launch rates for unmanned spaceflight have declined rapidly since the end of the cold war actually bringing launch costs UP, not down significantly and there is little perspective for that to fundamentally change.
Today's technological advances are mainly in information and communication technology and maybe regenerative energy.

On other aspects: Helium-3 mining on Moon is a Myth. It's existence on moon in significant levels is a pure theoretical construct, mining and transporting it would be so difficult that the eventual energy you could produce from it would be less than what you need to bring it down to earth. Plus Helium-3 is not strictly required for fusion.

Apart from all this: This Prediction is about a SELF SUFFICIENT outpost, that is, one that does NOT depend on supply from earth.

ertertert


دردشة
منتديات
شات
يوتيوب
مون لايت

ugg boots

I like your article. and many yonth like ugg australia
cheap gucci shoes
ugg boots
uggs
ugg boots uk
gucci shoes sale,ugg boots sale and ugg boots uk it's very popular, Thanks. if you want to know soming about gucci shoes,you can click
men gucci shoes
women gucci boots and click
Classic Tall Ugg Boots
Classic Short Ugg Boots
UGG Classic Cardy
UGG Classic Short
UGG Classic Tall
UGG Nightfall
UGG Sundance
there are many ugg boots and chooes what you like.

ghd hair straighteners for sale

Your article is write very well, I like it very much ~
If you have any needs, they can provide the following for your reference:
ghd Hair Straightener
ugg boots
nike sb dunks
dunks sb
ghd straighteners
nike dunks
Bose on ear headphones
ghd Hair Straighteners
ugg sale
Hair straightener
ugg boots uk
Bose in ear headphones
I wish you have a wonderful day!Thank you.

geciktirici
sex shop
göğüs büyütücü
ereksiyon
sex shop
diyet
magazin
moda
dizi izle
film izle
dizi izle
reklam
kozmetik
erotik video
oyun
devlet
çizgi film
arkadaş
board
oyun
mp3
camur
kobi
sekshikayeleri
sohbet
kiralık vinç
satılık vinç

nike dunks

More and more people like to wear dunks sb basketball shoes.nike dunk sb-Strong grips,durable ankle support and very comfort.Nike dunks are the most desirable skate shoes.Get your Nike Dunk SB Now!Free shipping.
ugg boots uk
All kinds of adidas shoes On Sale.We hot sell the latest Adidas Shoes&
cheap adidas shoes.The products are first-class quality,
adidas shoes salewelcome you to purchase.
In the present lively world, food and clothing put on the line in our life have already to obtain the sublimation, life needs the entertainment, in the market shoes design is all kinds, ugg boots and classic ugg boots were the riotous multi-colors, each kinds of color and design are finitely looks like the young women''s hairstyle , every day them use the ghd Straighteners to changes themself hairstyle.Please pay attention to the ghd Hair Straighteners site .
People to enjoy music, a need for a high-quality sound equipment to show the moving melody to enhance the music quality of life,It is the use of bose headphones.Now Bose headphones for sale in hot,Let''s go to buy bose headphones.
ugg bailey button boots

buy wow gold

aion gold Japanese
Buy wow gold frigate hit
www.game4power.comfrigate hit
buy cheapest wow gold ship were injured
aion gold at least
buy aion gold aion gold three
www.aionkina.com members of the
cheap wow gold SDF
warcraft gold
wow gold and
buy cheap wow gold

aion online

aion gold |aion kina|aion kinah|aion power leveling|aion time card|aion cd key|aion accounts|buy aion gold|cheap aion gold|wow gold|wow power leveling|lineage 2 adena|lineage 2 power leveling|lineage 2 accounts|warhammer gold|warhammer power leveling|warhammer accounts|lotro gold |lotro power leveling|aoc gold|aoc power leveling

wow gold

wow gold|buy wow gold|cheap wow gold|wow gold|buy wow gold|cheap wow gold|aion kina|aion gold|buy aion gold|aion gold|aion kina|buy aion gold|

ugg boots

ugg boots sale-Warm ugg boots for all the family remain at the heart of our collection,find your favorite UGGs from stunning designs-ugg boots uk.
All kinds of adidas shoes On Sale.We hot sell the latest Adidas Shoes&
cheap adidas shoes.The products are first-class quality,
adidas shoes sale welcome you to purchase.
UGG Boots sale
uggs bailey button
Classic Tall UGG Boots
Classic Short UGG Boots
nike dunk high
bose in ear
ghd straighteners
ghd

MKV to WMV MAC##MKV to PSP MAC##MKV to iPod MAC##MKV to Xbox MAC##MKV to iPhone MAC##MKV to Apple TV MAC

Air jordan shoes

Air jordan 1
Air jordan 2
Air jordan 3
Air jordan 4
Air jordan 5
Air jordan 6
Air jordan 7
air jordan 8
air jordan 9
air jordan 10
air jordan 11
air jordan 12
air jordan 13
air jordan 14
air jordan 16
air jordan 17
air jordan 18
air jordan 19
air jordan 21
air jordan 22
air jordan 23

gucci men's shoes

one day i went shopping outside,and in an gucci shoes store,I found some kinds of gucci shoes i love most.they are:
ed hardy mens tops ed hardy mens tops ed hardy mens hoodies ed hardy mens hoodies ed hardy mens jeans ed hardy mens jeans ed hardy mens wwim trunks ed hardy mens wwim trunks ed hardy mens underwear ed hardy mens underwear ed hardy mens shoes ed hardy mens shoes ed hardy womens swimwear ed hardy womens swimwear ed hardy womenst-shirt ed hardy womenst-shirt ed hardy womens tops ed hardy womens tops ed hardy womens tanks ed hardy womens tanks ed hardy womens hoodies ed hardy womens hoodies ed hardy womens jeans ed hardy womens jeans

ed hardy

links of london Sweetie Bracelets links of london Sweetie Bracelets
links of london Friendship Bracelets links of london Friendship Bracelets

ugg sale

I would like to buy ugg australia,ugg sale,ugg boots sale,uggs ,cheap uggs,nike dunk,UGG Bailey Button boots,nike sb for sale,UGG Nightfall boots,nike sb,UGG Classic Cardy Boots,UGG Classic tall boots,nike dunk high,UGG cardy boots,button ugg boots,bailey button ugg,ugg button boots,Bailey Button boots,discount nike sb,Michael jordan shoes,genuine ugg boots
and so on.

ugg boots

ugg boots,ugg boots sale,discount ugg boots,Nike dunk sb, uggs ,UGG Bailey Button boots,nike dunk low,UGG Classic boots,nike sb dunk,new nike sb,UGG Classic short boots,UGG Nightfall boots,cheap nike dunks,UGG Classic tall boots,Button ugg boots,Bailey Button ugg,UGG Button boots,Bailey Button boots.

chat emanuel chat kaynanı varyaa lollarım cinsel sohbet sohbet alexx
chat dogum günü sözleri amelemisin?
chat siteleri kabul et lan kameralı sohbet
chat siteleri sohbet siteleri hoşt köpek kizlarla sohbet
chat sitesi izlemeye bıkmayacaksınız. irc forumları
sohbet odaları and sohbet odaları
sohbet kızlarla sohbet sohbet odaları bedava sohbet

buZ

chat siteleri |sohbet|yonja|forum siteleri|mirc indir|sohbet|yonja|sohbet|sohbet|
kizlarla sohbet|dini sohbet|islami sohbet|sohbet/sohbet odalarisohbet|netlog|yonja|sohbet chat
cinsel sohbet
porno izle
toplist ekle

sohbetland

sohbet
chat
sohbetchat
chatsohbet
muhabbet
resim
resimler
resimler
sohbet
chat
sohbetchat
kızlarla sohbet
bayanlarla sohbet
bedava sohbet
bedava chat
radyo dinle
radyo dinle

Ugg

I love ugg boots salejordan shoesugg boots ukair jordanscardy ugg bootsUGG Classic MiniClassic Cardy UggsNightfall UGG BootsClassic Tall UGGsClassic Short UGGsSundance UGGs Boots

ugg boots sale

ugg boots sale at a time when large heat has set off a winter 08/09 to Ewha.Outlines the warm wool winter fashion degree to wool crocheted wool ugg boots uk to join after the body does not stimulate your skin soft, soft comfort UP. Fashion can not without ugg boots presence in Winter.and ugg boots have many series.such as:
UGG Bailey Button boots
ugg nightfall
ugg classic and
button ugg boots
bailey button ugg
ugg button boots

re

hiphop | rap | hiphop rap | chat sohbet | porno izle | porno | porno siteleri | sikiş izle | sikiş | sikiş | hosting | seks izle | sex izle |chat siteleri sex izle | chat | gay chatkelebek chat | kelebek sohbet |sex izle | zorla sikiş izle

Gucci Monogram
Gucci Tote Handbags
Cheap Gucci Handbags
Gucci Abbey D
UGG Women's Highkoo
UGG Women's Knightsbridge
UGG Classic Tall Romantic Flower
UGG Classic Tall stamp
Ugg Coquette Slipper
Ugg handbags
UGG Kid's Classic
UGG Classic Mini
UGG Classic Tall
UGG Sundance Limited Edition
Fendi Handbags

safdf

Stainless steel pipe and tubing are used for a variety of reasons: to resist corrosion and oxidation, to resist high temperatures, for cleanliness .Our seamless steel pipe products are popular all over the world with high quality, competitive price, fast delivery and efficient .The thickness of liquid film showing the maximum value of the weight loss which is due to cavitation erosion, is larger on the sintered metal of higher.how to adjust PVC window? my bathroom window along the bottom left corner now has a gap of at least 10-15mm is there any way to adjust the window 3 Pair Pack performance sport socks with Lycra and fully cushioned sole.the Leader of China Queuing System. It is specialized in Queuing System, esp. Queue Management SystemWith ten of years’experience in manufacturing of packaging machinery,the company mainly provide overwrapping machine, Overwrappers Machine, folding packing machine. Our overwrapping machines is in high qualityAluminium foil is an important material in laminates and has wide application in food packaging.Buy highest quality Omega replica watches at cheap wholesale price.iwc replica watch is the hottest and the latest design in our online website
tempered glass

dsafd

look for Air Jordan Shoes and Cheap Air Jordans or Cheap Jordan Shoes in the website is the Wholesale Jordan Shoes in the website ,some people like to buy jordan shoes or asking the jordan shoes for sale .we cna say come here .best you loke air force ones .ohter as nike dunksor air force shoes is very cheap , the nike air force 1 is very good and cheap air force 1 that u want ,just for air max 95 and if u want to go buy the air force af1 or retro air jordans.nike acg boots.come here is u best choose

Oh my god diziler or pornolar Yes, porno or sex I need this.
Those sikiş cats sex don’t look tortured, hikaye or telefonda sex they seem lida comfortable.
Trust me, porno filmler need or sexy videolar if you put a cat zayıflama in something travesti it doesn’t klipler want to be biber hapı wearing, film indir even a standard cat penis büyütücü collar, they would penis büyütücü take it off sex shop instantly.
iizle.net ~
seksi videolar ~
sıcak videolar ~
ateşli sevişmeler ~
iizle.net ~
ppornolar.com ~
ddiziler.com ~
bitmeyenhikayeler.com ~
video ~
telefonda sex ~
zayiflat.net ~
yutuvideo.com ~

Comments are temporarily closed.

Due to SPAM problems we have disabled commenting on Long Bets until we can institute automated filtering. Sorry for the inconvenience.