Bet 88
Major online internet useage research firms will record that over 3 billion people in 2025 managed their incoming and outgoing digital information using a graphical user interface based on Quadrant Theory - as described in Marshall McLuhan's "Tetrad" model in Laws of Media, Ken Wilber's Holon in Sex, Ecology Spirituality, and R Buckminster Fuller's Tetrahedral structures in Synergetics.
Re: Bet 88
Posted by Paul Blay
on Oct 17, 02002 at 06:24PM
Not meaning this in a nasty way, but this bet might well be categorised as a nice bit of publicity for $1,000 :-)
If Long Bets really takes off, that web-link in the bet details might produce rather more than $1,000 bits of business.
It Does Sound More Like Publicity Than a Bet
But it *is* phrased as a testable bet, so I'm not one to complain.
That said, it doesn't seem to invite a lot of popular debate. It doesn't actually describe "Quadrant Theory", and most of what it says about this theory sounds a lot like what futurists claimed radio would do, but, apparently, has still not done.
I'm also more than a little suspicious of the claim that the web was "incorrectly engineered as an extension of television".
This generalization -- which I think is desperately wrong -- may have been intended only to apply to a fraction of the technology involved in the web. That could be a perfectly reasonable argument, but not necessarily relevant.
Anyhow, the bettor has made an assertion, but not, I feel, a case to support it. I can't be too impressed by the mere citation of experts who claim their own ideas are great. The McLuhans, et al, may very well be sure that they're onto something, but they have a vested interest in saying so.
The website is down...
www.cloverfoundation.com doesn't seem to say anything about quadrant theory anymore. I think this one's a lost cause.
Please sign in to comment.